Ben Mezrich’s “Straight Flush” Literary Fraud, Part 3: The Biggest Lie About the Plane-Crash Story

Ben Mezrich’s “Straight Flush” Literary Fraud, Part 3: The Biggest Lie About the Plane-Crash Story

straight-flush-2Understanding the depths of authorial fraud committed by Ben Mezrich in his latest book, Straight Flush, requires nothing more complex than a simple comparison of the story as Mezrich tells it against the facts as they actually occurred.

One of the key elements to the Absolute Poker story is a plane crash that occurred at Costa Rica’s Juan Santamaria Airport on September 3, 2007.  Onboard the small Sabreliner jet, which SAE fratboy Hilt Tatum IV had rented and brought over from Panama, were Hilt and his new wife, Scott Tom and his pregnant girlfriend, and the jet’s pilot and co-pilot.  None were seriously injured, and the Tatums and Toms hopped a different plane the following day and continued on with their planned trip to Antigua and other Caribbean islands.

The plane crash will figure in again in this expose’s Part 5, “The Scandal Timeline Falsification,” adding even more proof to how intentional and fraudulent Mezrich’s latest work really is.  In the days after it occurred, anecdotes quickly surfaced on numerous poker and sportsbook forums that Tatum’s and Tom’s luggage, abandoned as they fled the fire threat at the plane crash scene, included a duffel bag containing $2-3 million and an unknown quantity of drugs.

It’s recast just a bit differently on p. 269 of Straight Flush.  Here’s Mezrich’s take, as recounted by the fratboys:

By the time they were released from the hospital — more a precautionary stay than due to the severity of their cuts and bruises — word of the accident had already made it onto a variety of online local and international news site and was rapidly spreading through the blogs. Scott’s phone was gone, lost somewhere in the wreckage, which was now entirely presided over by agents from the FAA, since it had been an American-built airplane. They had to use Hilt’s phone to check in with everyone to tell them that they were okay. By the second person they called, they realized that the story, spreading electronically at first, but eventually into newspapers as well, was turning into something out of a Hollywood thriller.

“This is ridiculous,” Hilt said as he hung up the phone. “Now they’re reporting that there was three million dollars and a bunch of coke in a suitcase on the back of the plane, and that you’re on the run to Colombia. I’ve never gone near cocaine — and where the hell did they get the three million dollars?”

Scott shook his head, bewildered. He was watching an urban legend generating right in front of him, and there was nothing he could do about it. What the hell — it was just too perfect to fight. A high-flying American cowboy from Montana, fleeing Costa Rica to Colombia with millions of dollars and mountains of coke.

Mezrich’s implication in this excerpt is crystal clear: these allegations were false. The real truth about the Sabreliner crash took until 2011 to appear, when Costa Rican authorities finally confirmed that the stories were true, and that investigators really did find a duffel bag containing $3 million in the Sabreliner’s wrecked fuselage.  [Note: The “Colombia” referenced is in connection to the original flight’s scheduled refueling stop, halfway to Antigua, in Cartagena, Colombia.]

I’ve archived several news reports about this.  Here’s one example, from the Tico Times, one of Costa Rica’s largest newspapers:

In 2007, a small private plane had a minor accident during takeoff at Costa Rica’s Juan Santamaría International Airport. While investigating the accident, airport officials stumbled upon something unusual.

Inside the plane authorities found a bag containing $3 million in cash. The plane was headed for Colombia, and one of its passengers was Scott Tom, owner of the online gambling website Absolute Poker. One of the world’s more popular online gambling sites, Absolute Poker was based at a non-descript office building in Rohrmoser, west of San José, under the name Innovative Data Solutions (IDS).

The multi-million dollar discovery prompted the Public Prosecutor’s Office to begin monitoring Tom, who investigators suspected of laundering money earned from U.S. poker players and dispersing it into bank accounts throughout the world.

“When we learned of the money on the plane and that Scott Tom had been on the flight, we began to investigate the financial and economic activities that he had in Costa Rica,” Guillermo Hernández, adjunct prosecutor at the Prosecutor’s Office’s Financial Crimes Division, told The Tico Times this week. “We were able to determine that there was an important flow of money from the United States to Costa Rica and that it was being invested in different forms in Costa Rica.” [bold emphasis mine]

But Hernández said the Prosecutor’s Office couldn’t verify the money’s source.

Four years later, and with a little help from the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the Prosecutor’s Office began to build a case that allegedly linked the funds to illegal online gambling operations. Investigators believed they had enough evidence that money laundering and bank fraud were occurring.

The $3 million from the Sabreliner crash in 2007 was the key event that allowed Costa Rica’s OIJ agents to raid Scott Tom’s home and the AP offices in conjunction with the US’s 2011 Black Friday indictments.  Mezrich didn’t mention that all at, and glosses over the raid on Tom (who had already gone on the lam) in a couple of brief sentences.

In other words, the fratboys told lies to Mezrich, and Mezrich lied to his readers.  So now you know.  It’s not even close to debatable.

COMMENTS

Leave a Comment

*

LATEST NEWS

filter by

Dan Katz

8th February 2020 // Gossip, News, Online Poker Action

Phil Galfond Down €750,000 to VeniVidi1993 in Galfond Challenge

Look, I don’t typically make a habit of feeling bad when people of means lose money, but oh man, I am starting to get...

Dan Katz

2nd February 2020 // News, Online Poker Action

PokerStars, partypoker Launching Dueling Bounty Tourney Series on Super Bowl Sunday

The year 2020 is already one-twelfth gone. It seems like just yesterday that Larry David was arguing that it was too...

Haley Hintze

31st January 2020 // Misc, News, Poker Tournaments

Coronavirus Outbreak Forces Postponement of Triton Jeju Series

The Triton Super High Roller Series scheduled for mid-Februry in Jeju, South Korea has become the first poker event...

Dan Katz

31st January 2020 // News, Poker Tournaments

High Roller Series Schedule Released for 2020 WSOP

The Super Bowl (oh wait, I don’t want to get sued… the “BIG GAME”) is this weekend, but once the offseason...

Haley Hintze

31st January 2020 // Industry, Misc, News, Poker Tournaments

Still a Waiting Game for Michigan Online Poker

Would-be Michigan online poker players are dealing with mixed emotions in the wake of news that fully legalized and...

Dan Katz

26th January 2020 // Industry, Misc, News, Op-ed

PokerStars Founder Isai Scheinberg Finally Surrenders to U.S. Authorities

Couldn’t avoid the inevitable If there was an online poker Mount Rushmore, Isai Scheinberg’s face would almost...